Username:
Password:
Remember Me?
   Lost your password?
Search



Colin McRae Dirt 2

Dirt 2: DirectX 9 vs. DirectX 11 graphics compared [Top article of December 2009]

The PC version of Colin McRae Dirt 2 offers a DirectX 9 and a DirectX 11 rendering path. PC Games Hardware explains and demonstrates the differences.
2009 has come to an end and PC Games Hardware takes a look at the past year. What caught the attention of our users and the people on the web? To answer this question we checked our statistics and searched for the most popular articles of the year. Today we want to reveal the top article of December 2009, which has also been the third most popular article of the whole year.

Original article
Colin McRae Dirt 2
Original article November 23, 2009
Colin McRae Dirt 2: Engine
Codemasters delayed the PC version of Colin McRae: Dirt 2 in order to upgrade the Ego Engine of the racing game with DirectX 11 support. The cross platform architecture is capable of all modern rendering tricks but some are only used with DX11. The current API offers Hardware Tessellation which is used for a more detailed audience, tessellated cloth (banners and flags) as well as a more realistic visualization of water with more waves and splashes. Due to the Full Floating Point HDR Illumination (FP16) and High Definition Ambient Occlusion calculated via DirectCompute, Post Effects like Motion blur and filtered Soft Shadows especially the light and shadow effects of Colin McRae: Dirt 2 are very realistic. Furthermore Dirt 2 receives a benefit from multi-core CPUs because of the multithreading feature of DirectX 11.

Colin McRae Dirt 2: DirectX 9 vs. DirectX 11
In a direct comparison the differences on the audience only become noticeable if you get close and pay attention - some more polygons in the right place make the figures look a little better. The flying flags are "nice to have” while the improved water visualization is really good: The car really ploughs through the water and builds up a little bow wave - additional particles on splashes make the whole scene more realistic. But the biggest difference between DirectX 9 and DirectX 11 is the illumination. Due to HDAO and nice Post Effects the visual appearance of Dirt 2 with DirectX 11 is less "overbright” and smoother. The more realistic look of the DirectX 11 version might convince some players, since there have already been mods for Race Driver Grid that were reducing exactly those warm colors and thus created a more real appearance.

For benchmarks showing the difference in performance between DirectX 9 and DirectX 11 please refer to our Dirt 2 benchmark article.

Update: December 1, 2009
AMD published new comparison shots between DirectX 9 and DirectX 11 on the company's page at flicker.com. you can find the pictures in our gallery and below we have on click comparisons showing inactive Ambient Occlusion (DX9) and active High Definition Ambient Occlusion (DX11) as well as cloth Tessellation.

Click to select DirectX version (Attention: Screenshot detail only)
Colin McRae Dirt 2


Click to select DirectX version (Attention: Screenshot detail only)
Colin McRae Dirt 2


Picture gallery  (enlarge to view source)




Click to select DirectX version (Attention: Screenshot detail only!)
Colin McRae Dirt 2


Colin McRae Dirt 2: Tessellated water with DX11
 
Colin McRae Dirt 2: Tessellated water with DX11 [Source: view picture gallery]


Click to select DirectX version (Attention: Screenshot detail only!)
Colin McRae Dirt 2



--
Author: Marc Sauter (Jan 03, 2010)






Advertisement

Comments (14)

Comments 11 to 14  Read all comments here!
dried Re: Dirt 2: DirectX 9 vs. DirectX 11 graphics compared [Top article of December 2009]
Member
01.12.2009 14:13
This new first picture looks more like ambient occlusion on (dx11) and off(dx9).
The second one looks nice, but i believe physx can do better (with a huge impact on performance, of course)
DarkStalker Bullshit graphic
Junior Member
01.12.2009 13:33
Quote: (Originally Posted by Gameslove)
What about Directx 10 (10.1) render comparation? Game hasn't Directx 10(10.1) mode? Directx 10(10.1) cards not able run Directx 11 mode without tessellation, like Heaven Benchmark‎? Directx 10(10.1) cards not able do Directx 10 (10.1) features that have Directx 11 mode?


My man, there is no directx 10(10.1) probably because they can't show us any difference between dx10 and dx11. Just wait the game hits out, many sites will then offer real comparison between dx9, dx10 and dx11. Until then this is only Codemasters propaganda strategy, but they won't fool us here...
Gameslove Re: Dirt 2: DirectX 9 vs. DirectX 11 graphics compared [Top article of December 2009]
Junior Member
24.11.2009 14:01
What about Directx 10 (10.1) render comparation? Game hasn't Directx 10(10.1) mode? Directx 10(10.1) cards not able run Directx 11 mode without tessellation, like Heaven Benchmark‎? Directx 10(10.1) cards not able do Directx 10 (10.1) features that have Directx 11 mode?

Copyright © 2014 by Computec Media GmbH      About/Imprint  •  Terms/Conditions